Pirates of the Caribbean
Overview
LEGO Pirates of the Caribbean appeared in two distinct waves: a first wave in 2011 covering the original trilogy and On Stranger Tides, and a single-set second wave in 2017 coinciding with Dead Men Tell No Tales. The sets are naval-scale builds dominated by ships, docks, and island fortresses, with minifigure rosters drawn from the film casts — Jack Sparrow, Elizabeth Swann, Will Turner, Barbossa, Davy Jones, and a broad range of crew and villain figures. The theme is fully retired, with the Disney/Bruckheimer licence having lapsed after the 2017 wave. No new sets have been produced since, and the film franchise's uncertain status following the disappointing performance of Dead Men Tell No Tales means a licence revival is not imminent. The catalogue is closed. The first wave in particular carries strong collector heritage. The 2011 Black Pearl remains one of the most sought-after retired LEGO ships, and the first-wave figure catalogue includes some of the most visually distinctive villain designs in LEGO's licensed history — Davy Jones in particular stands as one of the more spectacular minifigure executions of that era.
Key Characters in the Pirates of the Caribbean Theme
The Pirates of the Caribbean catalogue covers 34 characters across 53 minifigure variants — with Captain Jack Sparrow unsurprisingly leading at 9 variants, followed by Hector Barbossa at 4. The striking stat is that 28 of those 34 characters — 82% of the roster — are represented by only a single variant, reflecting the theme's relatively compact production history and the broad character spread of the films. For collectors, that means the vast majority of POTC character acquisitions are simultaneously a first and final purchase — there is no alternative variant to wait for or compare against.
View all characters
Captain Jack Sparrow
Hector Barbossa
Cannibal
Elizabeth Swann Turner
Joshamee Gibbs
Will Turner
Captain Armando Salazar
Angelica
Largest Sets by Piece Count in the Pirates of the Caribbean Theme
The POTC catalogue spans the 2011 first wave and the smaller 2017 Dead Men Tell No Tales wave, covering ship builds, dock settings, and island environments. The flagship 2011 sets hold the most value, however the ships of 4184 - The Black Pearl and 4195 - Queen Anne's Revenge and the 2017 71042 - Silent Mary are the most sought-after. This can be attributed to not just a healthy range of unique minifigures, but because ships in general (like trains), always attract a premium when it comes to LEGO sets.
View all 15 sets
Silent Mary
Queen Anne's Revenge
The Black Pearl
Whitecap Bay
The London Escape
The Mill
The Cannibal Escape
Isla De Muerta
Notable Minifigures
POC031 - Davy Jones (£106.73) is the standout figure in the theme — a single-variant, single-set character with one of the most visually spectacular minifigure designs in the LEGO licensed catalogue, and the unambiguous price leader. POC006 - Angelica (£57.50) commands a premium driven by her single-variant status and limited set distribution. POC032 - Maccus (£31.92) illustrates how even supporting characters can drive premium prices through a combination of scarcity and visually powerful design qualities.
View all 53 minifigures
Davy Jones
Angelica
Hector Barbossa - Pearl Dark Gray Coat
Captain Salazar
Maccus
Captain Jack Sparrow - White Shirt, Dark Blue Vest with Filigree, Bandana
Lieutenant Lesaro
Carina Smyth
Collectability & Investment Insights
Pirates of the Caribbean carries Brickpit's standard licensed multiplier, but secondary market dynamics are driven primarily by the first wave's age and the visual quality of specific figures. Davy Jones and the Flying Dutchman crew variants from the 2011 sets are the clearest examples: distinctive designs, limited production relative to later LEGO ship releases, and villain aesthetics that consistently command collector premiums. The price spread within the theme is meaningful. Jack Sparrow variants from common sets trade at modest premiums; the most distinctive villain and creature figures from the original wave trade at multiples above that. The collector variable that matters most in POTC is set of origin — figures from the larger, more expensive 2011 ships had lower production volumes and higher original price points, which has compressed supply more acutely than smaller entry-level sets from the same era. The strategic collector case for POTC rests on closed production, a decade-plus age premium on the 2011 wave, and strong visual distinctiveness for the best figures in the catalogue. The ceiling is partially capped by franchise uncertainty, but the floor is meaningfully supported — and has been for years.